Low-Energy Fridays: Can Advanced Recycling Offer New Ways to Handle Plastic Waste?
Depending on your age, when you think about plastics, your mind might replay a scene from The Graduate or Mean Girls. More likely, though, you simply look around and see the sheer amount of the material present in our daily lives, including in our phones, our cars, and the packaging we use to store food. It’s not news that plastics are everywhere. But advanced recycling may be another way to tackle this problem and is a technology that merits experimentation.
You’re probably also aware that most plastics are not biodegradable, meaning that they won’t naturally degrade. Throw a banana peel on the ground and, without any additional composting material, it will degrade within about two years. Throw a piece of plastic on the ground, however, and it will take 100 years or more (potentially much more) to break down into microplastics.
Instead of letting plastics pile up, recycling should be a great option. But, compared to nearly every other container or packaging material (paper, glass, aluminum, wood, etc.), plastic recycling recovery rates are incredibly low. About 70% of plastic containers and packaging that go through municipal waste systems wind up in a landfill–and that doesn’t include trash bags or single-use plates and cups.
This is because most plastic recycling today involves used plastic being shredded, washed, and melted down into new raw material (though that material is still the same type of plastic from start to finish). The process–which we’ll call “mechanical” recycling for the purposes of this piece–can cause degradation at the molecular level, meaning the material that comes out won’t be as strong as what went in. It also requires that plastic waste be sorted according to color and type, which can be complicated and expensive.
There is, however, another way. Or rather, a complementary process.
“Advanced” recycling allows plastic to be reconstituted into new products. Instead of the mechanical recycling process that begins and ends with the same type of material, advanced recycling uses heat and chemicals to break plastic material down to its molecular level and then uses this to create different materials. This process also allows for a wider array of plastics to be processed, more than mechanical recycling does.
Though still somewhat nascent, advanced recycling–also known as “chemical” recycling–is growing as an industry. But with that growth has come criticism. Opponents of advanced recycling claim that it’s not recycling at all and does more environmental harm than good. However, as with most things, the reality is a little more complicated than that.
For one, the emissions from advanced recycling can vary significantly depending on the method being used. And, while mechanical recycling may have fewer emissions, the lower quality of its outputs reduces its overall benefit compared to advanced recycling. In addition, advanced recycling offers opportunities to process at least some additional plastic waste that would otherwise wind up in landfills.
As for whether it’s real recycling or not, this all hinges on how we choose to define recycling. I don’t mean to be pedantic, but should a process only be considered recycling if the output matches the input (e.g., taking waste paper and processing it to get new usable paper)? There’s nothing wrong with such processes, but this view might be too constraining. Instead, it might be more useful to consider recycling a process by which any new material is made from old material.
This view opens up wider possibilities to handle plastic waste–namely, one that includes both mechanical and advanced recycling as part of a complementary process. In other words, the two shouldn’t be seen as mutually exclusive, but instead as different sets of tools to accomplish the overall goal of reducing waste.
The European Union seems to agree. Earlier this year, the European Commission issued new rules for recycling certain plastics. For the first time, the Commission established the ways in which advanced recycling can be used and made it clear that this process can complement mechanical recycling.
Now I know that bringing up Europeans in a discussion on American policy is a risky move. But I don’t think it’s a stretch to say that there is a general belief around the world that the Europeans have taken a more active role in addressing environmental issues than we have in the United States. So, I bring up the EU’s new rules as a counterpoint to some of the naysayers on this side of the Atlantic citing environmental issues as the reason not to pursue advanced recycling.
If nothing else, anything that might help us reduce plastic waste is worth at least exploring. Let’s try it out, get a bit of data, and determine if it still seems worth it. Keep or even increase mechanical plastic recycling, but don’t let it be the only approach. Let’s not stand in our own way on the road to reducing waste.