Why Don’t Americans Believe Crime is Falling, and What Should Law Enforcement Do About It?
Americans feel better about crime than they have in years—though still not nearly as good as the data suggests they should. In Gallup’s latest annual crime survey, 46 percent of adults said there is more crime in the United States than a year ago. The figure has been lower only once since Gallup began asking the question in 1989, and that was in the aftermath of the Sept. 11 attacks in 2001. Official statistics tell a far more encouraging story than the poll does. If the facts show crime is falling, why don’t more Americans believe it? And how can law enforcement take advantage of this decline in crime to prepare for the future?
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) data shows violent crime fell an estimated 9.3 percent in 2025. That is the largest one-year decline since national estimates began in 1936. The murder rate dropped to 4.1 per 100,000, matching its record low. The Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) victimization survey, which also counts crimes victims never report to police, found that the combined rate of rape or sexual assault, robbery, and aggravated assault fell 25 percent from 2024 to 2025. This good news has continued, with the FBI’s preliminary figures for the first half of 2026 showing violent crime down another 10.6 percent and murder down 23 percent compared with the same months of 2025. Put another way, as a nation we have had the fewest murders per capita in over 100 years.
Yet many Americans’ sense of danger has not caught up with the numbers, and that disconnect affects how police departments are funded and staffed, how they respond to community concerns, and how well they are able to solve cases.
Why the Gap Persists
Part of the answer is politics. Gallup’s data shows that perceptions of crime move with partisanship: an analysis of 25 years of Gallup surveys found that Americans feel safer when their party controls the White House. Another part is where people get their information. Coverage of rare, shocking crimes travels far on national news and social media, and visible signs of disorder in neighborhoods feel out of proportion to the crime actually occurring there. Police cannot fix partisanship or the news cycle, but they can publish neighborhood-level crime figures that residents of any party can check for themselves. Americans also tend to rate levels of crime in their own communities as lower than crime across the country, a pattern Gallup has found consistently since 1989. This suggests that what people experience firsthand is a better guide than national headlines.
Why Public Perception Matters for Police
Poor public perception also harms public cooperation with police. Investigators depend on victims and witnesses who come forward, and people who see their neighborhoods as dangerous and doubt that police can do anything about it are less likely to report a crime, give a statement, or testify. Federal victimization data shows that just under half of incidents of violence reached police in 2024, including fewer than one in four rapes and sexual assaults.
Most cases cannot be cleared—or solved—without that cooperation, and clearances have been falling for more than half a century. In the mid-1960s, police solved about nine in 10 homicides; by 2023, FBI figures show they solved roughly 58 percent. Other offenses fare far worse. In 2025, police cleared 28.4 percent of rapes, 35.8 percent of robberies, 18.6 percent of larcenies, 17.4 percent of burglaries, and 10.5 percent of motor vehicle thefts—a category whose clearance rate had hit a record low of 8.2 percent in 2023.
That is a problem because even a long prison sentence deters little when the odds of arrest are slim. People want crimes solved. Decades of research find that the chance of getting caught shapes criminal behavior far more than the punishment that might follow. Low clearance rates also give residents reason to doubt that police can protect them, and the relationship runs both ways: residents who think their local police usually solve killings are more inclined to share information and help investigations.
Clearance Gains Are Real, but Not Guaranteed
Clearance rates have risen since 2022, when the national violent crime clearance rate bottomed out below 37 percent, though they remain low by historical standards. FBI data shows police cleared 68.8 percent of murders in 2025, up from about half in 2021 and 2022, which one analysis suggests is the strongest showing in at least 25 years. Across all reported violent crimes, police solved slightly fewer than half in 2025.
Much of that improvement, however, reflects simple arithmetic: if detectives solve about the same number of murders while total murders fall, the clearance rate climbs on its own. For example, a department that solves 50 of 100 murders has a 50 percent clearance rate. If murders fall to 80 the next year and detectives again solve 50, the rate rises to about 63 percent, even though investigators did not solve a single additional case. Baltimore’s homicide clearance rate nearly doubled between 2022 and 2024, yet murder arrests rose only from 103 to 127.
A clearance also does not guarantee a conviction, and the FBI counts a case as cleared under a wide range of circumstances. Under the FBI’s current reporting rules, any arrest connected to a crime clears it. When police have identified a suspect and have enough evidence for an arrest but cannot make one, the case can also be cleared by “exceptional means,” for example, if the suspect has died, the victim will not cooperate, or prosecutors decline the case for a reason other than a lack of probable cause. Unless agencies use the current drop in new cases to work through their backlogs and strengthen their investigative units, clearance rates are likely to fall again if crime rises.
What Law Enforcement Should Do Now
Agencies should use the current decline in crime to build up their investigative ranks and strengthen ties with the communities they serve. Several priorities stand out.
- Reinvest in investigations. Fewer homicides give detectives time to work each case thoroughly, and Boston’s overhaul of its homicide unit shows how much that can raise clearances.
- Put more investigative effort into nonfatal shootings. Homicides are solved far more often than shootings in which the victim survives, and the gap comes down mostly to how much work investigators put in. Denver nearly tripled its arrest rate for nonfatal shootings after assigning a dedicated unit.
- Make the most of forensic evidence. Ballistic evidence helped Milwaukee raise its clearance rate for nonfatal shootings, yet DNA and ballistics results can take a year or more in some places. Agencies cannot clear lab backlogs on their own, but they can prioritize testing in cases where a lead is most likely to produce an arrest and partner with regional labs and federal programs to share the load.
- Track perception alongside crime. Survey residents regularly on safety and trust, and report results such as fewer shootings rather than counts of arrests.
- Publish clearance data honestly. Report clearances alongside arrests, as Missouri now requires statewide.
- Stabilize staffing. Sworn personnel numbers have recovered to 2022 levels but remain below 2020, so now is the time to hire and train investigators and analysts. Houston’s homicide clearance rate climbed from 52 percent in 2020 to 69 percent in 2022 after the department added about 20 investigators and put new detectives through specialized training.
The Bottom Line
Gallup’s numbers make clear that a drop in crime does not, on its own, restore public confidence. Police can win that confidence back by solving more cases, being candid about how many they solve, and treating victims and witnesses in ways that make them willing to cooperate. With crime continuing to decline, agencies have an opening to make progress on each front, and they should make the most of it while it lasts.