Fraud and Scams—Part 1: What happens when you report a scam to the police?
This is the first post in a two-part series on why law enforcement struggles to investigate fraud and scams. Part 1 follows what happens to a scam report once it is filed; Part 2 looks at why local law enforcement agencies are unable do more and what would help them fill the gap in scam reporting.
A 71-year-old widower in Brentwood, California, got a text from a wrong number and, after three months of daily messaging with someone named “Tina,” moved his entire $1 million retirement account through cryptocurrency exchanges into what he believed was an investment account. By the time his stepdaughter recognized the scam, the money was gone. He contacted the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the U.S. Secret Service, but none of the agencies could help—and he might now lose his house to the tax bill on the withdrawal.
Cases like this are part of a global criminal industry that the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime estimates to have caused $88 billion to $114 billion in losses in 2025 in East and Southeast Asia, Australia, and New Zealand alone. It has also fueled human trafficking. Yet most victims never report: Only about one in five tell local police, while roughly 13 to 14 percent report to federal agencies like the FBI or FTC. Three in four of those who stay silent say they assumed reporting would not help them get their money back. This piece addresses where reports that are filed ultimately end up (and how they get there).
What do local police do with a scam report?
Local law enforcement agencies often take the report, refer the victim to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) or the FTC, and file it as an isolated local case. One witness told Congress in 2026 that these cases often fail to reach the federal investigators who could connect them to a larger criminal network. Even when a department wants to help, a local detective with no suspect nearby and no way to trace the money has no investigative lead to follow. The current reporting system is simply not designed for crimes committed online from another country.
IC3 is the FBI’s central hub for reporting cyber-enabled crime. It received just over a million complaints in 2025, with nearly $20.9 billion in reported losses—an increase of 26 percent over the prior year. Its Recovery Asset Team, which asks banks to freeze stolen funds while still in the recipient’s account, froze $679 million in 2025, while Operation Level Up reached 3,780 cryptocurrency investment victims in the middle of being scammed, saving an estimated $226 million. Although these efforts return real money to victims, the amount of frozen funds covers only a small fraction of what was lost, and actual losses are far higher than what victims report. IC3 does not take on individual cases like the California widower’s; rather, it analyzes complaints and refers them to other agencies that decide whether to investigate.
Which federal agencies investigate fraud and scams?
Several federal agencies share responsibility for fraud and scams:
- Department of Justice (DOJ). As the department’s investigative arm, the FBI runs IC3 and leads elder fraud task forces that include local officers. The Transnational Elder Fraud Strike Force pursues foreign schemes aimed at seniors, while the Scam Center Strike Force, launched in November 2025, targets Southeast Asian scam compounds and has restrained (or effectively frozen) more than $1 billion in cryptocurrency.
- Postal Inspection Service. Investigates scams perpetrated via mail, including money mules who move stolen funds on behalf of scammers.
- Secret Service. Runs the Cyber Fraud Task Forces. Its director told Congress that the agency recovered more than $751 million in fiscal year 2025, returning $472 million to victims.
- Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) and Internal Revenue Service Criminal Investigation (IRS-CI).These agencies investigate crimes that cross U.S. borders or involve tax violations. HSI seized $192 million in cryptocurrency across all of its cases in fiscal year 2024, and IRS-CI reported $149 million in assets seized in cyber-related cases in fiscal year 2025.
- Department of the Treasury. The department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control imposes sanctions on scam networks, and the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) uses anti-money-laundering law to cut launderers off from U.S. banks. FinCEN’s Rapid Response Program, which asks foreign governments to stop and return stolen wire transfers, has recovered more than $1 billion for about 5,800 U.S. victims since 2015.
- Federal Trade Commission. As a civil enforcement agency with no criminal authority, the FTC runs the Consumer Sentinel complaint database and goes after U.S.-based businesses that help foreign scammers (e.g., a payment processing company collecting money for overseas scams).
However, these agencies are more focused on dismantling criminal networks than on solving individual cases. Released in October 2026, a congressional committee’s minority-staff review found that neither the FTC nor the Department of Homeland Security or the State Department could say how much of the money they recovered came from scam compound cases. Even the head of the Scam Center Strike Force has acknowledged that federal rules for returning seized cryptocurrency are slow and unlikely to make most victims whole. And because those who do report are more likely to go to local police than the FBI or FTC, local law enforcement remains an essential part of any response.
Why aren’t scams counted in crime statistics?
Crime statistics help determine where police resources go, yet the national systems that produce those statistics capture only a small share of scams. The FBI’s National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) recognizes only two cybercrimes: hacking and identity theft. As a result, scam reports are logged under a general fraud category (e.g., wire fraud). In 2024, 116,000 fraud offenses—just a fraction of the roughly 860,000 complaints IC3 received that year—were flagged as having occurred online. Furthermore, the two federal complaint systems that do track scams produce different totals: IC3’s annual report noted $20.9 billion in losses for 2025, while the FTC reported about $16 billion.
Signed in 2022, the Better Cybercrime Metrics Act gave the DOJ two years to add a cybercrime category to NIBRS; however, as of late 2025, the system still recognized only two such offenses. A National Academies panel concluded last year that no one in government is responsible for pulling the scattered data together, and in March 2026, the Government Accountability Office informed Congress that there is still no government-wide estimate of scam losses and that officials at 13 separate agencies were unaware of any national strategy.
As a result, estimates of how much Americans lose to scams each year vary widely, from $68 billion to $196 billion depending on the method and the year measured. Counts based on complaints depend on victims coming forward; however, only about a quarter of Americans who lose money to an online scam or attack tell law enforcement—meaning even the best figures cannot capture how widespread this type of fraud has become.
What does this mean for the next victim?
In a case like the widower’s, the report is unlikely to reach anyone who can act on it. His local police department has no suspect to arrest, IC3’s Recovery Asset Team works through banks while his money was converted to cryptocurrency, and the federal agencies capable of tracing those funds focus on large criminal networks rather than individual cases. And because crime statistics do not capture what happened to him, local officials have no clear way to see how big the problem is in their own communities.
Many victims seem to understand this, which helps explain why 79 percent never report the incident to local police. Part 2 of this series will examine why local law enforcement agencies—which remain largely reactive and bound by jurisdiction—are unable to fill that gap and what it would take to change that.