Incoming insurance commissioner endorses premium-raising reforms
It’s a new day in Georgia following the Democrats’ sweep of statewide offices, and with newly elected officials come new ideas, or at least recycled ones. As Inauguration Day creeps closer, officials are slowly laying out their policy agendas. Some of them are raising serious alarms – especially proposals related to insurance that are poised to penalize good drivers, raise rates on most Georgians and particularly burden senior citizens.
In a recent interview, Insurance and Safety Fire Commissioner-elect Keisha Waites remarked, “There’s not anybody, I think, that lives in the state of Georgia that has not been impacted by the exorbitant cost of automobile insurance, homeowners premiums and things of that nature.” Then she outlined her plan to make insurance more affordable and institute more fairness in the industry.
At face value, those seem like unobjectionable goals. How she intends on achieving her vision of them is another matter altogether. To do so, she hopes to work with the Georgia General Assembly to “ban the idea of utilizing credit scores as well as ZIP codes to determine risk. Those have nothing to do with calculating your risk as it relates to your insurance premiums,” she alleges.
These reforms would be a disaster for the insurance market and consumers. In order for insurers to accurately set rates for customers, they need a broad set of predictive data. If they charge too much, they lose business, and if they charge too little, then they risk bankruptcy. While credit-based information and ZIP codes may seem irrelevant to setting insurance premiums, reams of research show otherwise.
“Credit-based insurance scores are effective predictors of risk under automobile policies. They are predictive of the number of claims consumers file and the total cost of those claims. The use of scores is therefore likely to make the price of insurance better match the risk of loss posed by the consumer,” according to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
“Use of credit-based insurance scores may result in benefits for consumers,” the FTC wrote. “For example, scores permit insurance companies to evaluate risk with greater accuracy, which may make them more willing to offer insurance to higher-risk consumers for whom they would otherwise not be able to determine an appropriate premium.” Moreover, they are not unfairly discriminatory. As the National Association of Insurance Commissioners noted, “A credit-based insurance score cannot use any personal information to determine your score.”
They are only one of a host of factors considered, but they are critically important and help keep premiums down for most people. Just look at Washington state, which tried to ban insurers from considering them. “Without the use of credit scoring, insurance premiums could increase as much as 60% for some insurance carriers, thus increasing your insurance premiums significantly,” PCGR Insurance noted.
This would particularly harm those on fixed incomes, especially senior citizens, and fortunately for Washington, a court overturned the ban. However, a handful of other states have imposed their own, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan, which aren’t states known for healthy and thriving insurance markets.
Similarly, banning the use of ZIP codes when determining premiums will backfire spectacularly. Some ZIP codes are known for more traffic congestion, accidents and theft. Those are risks insurers must account for to accurately and fairly price insurance. It would be unfair to charge someone who lives in a low-risk ZIP code the same rate as someone in a high-risk ZIP code. A ban on the inclusion of ZIP codes in ratemaking would simply result in more people paying higher premiums.
Waites also discussed the need for more competition and “to make sure that the process is streamlined to make it easier for companies who want to come into our state to do business.” That is a better approach to lowering insurance costs, but I would be remiss if I didn’t mention the Peach State has a competitive market. “Georgia has over 400 personal home and automobile insurers,” Insurance News Net reported last year.
Perhaps the best approach for Waites to bring down insurance costs is to, well, wait, and let the previously enacted insurance reforms take full effect. They have already started to make their impact. Thanks to the work of the Legislature, many insurance rates are falling. As I reported in these pages earlier this year, various insurers have filed rate decrease requests totaling anywhere from 2% to 10% in a single year. This is an astounding volte-face for an industry that was once beleaguered by rampant lawsuit abuse.
The insurance industry may not get much sympathy from consumers or regulators, and whatever premiums cost, people will always think they are too high. While I believe Waites wants to find ways to help, some of her proposed reforms will do the opposite, and Georgians can ill afford another added expense.